The main page has a place
Use it when you still want to look around and have not picked an item type yet.
Quick comparison
Start with the main page if you are still exploring. Open a category page when you already know the item type.
The best page is the one that matches how close you already are to making a choice.
Use it when you still want to look around and have not picked an item type yet.
At that point, shoes or jackets is easier than opening a mixed page again.
It is easier to keep going when the page matches the item type you already have in mind.
Use a broad search when you do not yet know the product type, brand style or category. It is useful for discovery, but it becomes less efficient once the item family is obvious.
Broad search is a discovery tool, not the best final route for every buying decision.
Once you save several links from the same family, move out of broad search and into the matching route so later checks stay consistent.
Open a category route when you already know you want shoes, hoodies, pants, bags or accessories. It removes unrelated results and makes the next QC questions more predictable.
That makes the page feel calmer because every follow-up check belongs to the same item family.